The age-old geographical rivalry between New York City and Los Angeles has fueled cultural debates for decades, but for Coveteur social creative lead Natasha Sheridan, the two metropolises serve different, equally vital purposes in her personal and professional life. While her home base in Los Angeles offers a relaxed, slower pace of life and easy weekend strolls through the iconic Melrose Trading Post, the East Coast presents an entirely different kind of energy. For Sheridan, New York City provides a gratifying, high-stakes challenge and a wellspring of limitless creative influence that she considers essential to her demanding role in digital media.
Though Los Angeles remains her reliable home base where she can center herself, Sheridan routinely returns to the East Coast twice a year. These biannual pilgrimages allow her to completely immerse herself in the delicious, unpredictable chaos of New York. Over time, those frequent visits have given her an insider’s perspective on the city, enabling her to compile a curated itinerary of local favorites that rivals any seasoned resident’s guide. Furthermore, she has perfected the art of packing for the city’s notoriously dynamic environment, relying on a dependable collection of 100 percent cotton pieces to keep her comfortable and stylish throughout her fast-paced trips.
When she touches down in Manhattan, Sheridan’s itinerary immediately points toward some classic neighborhood staples. Arthur’s Tavern sits firmly at the top of her list, serving as her ultimate destination for live jazz paired with a delicious burger. Describing the atmosphere, she notes that the vibes there are immaculate, while the historic venue’s location makes it remarkably easy to bop around the West Village afterward. When she needs a quick, satisfying bite during a hectic schedule packed with meetings and fashion events, Little Maven becomes her go-to spot for a power lunch, specifically for their standout Caesar cups.
Balancing a demanding work trip in New York rarely leaves room for downtime, but when she manages to carve out a few precious moments of rest, Sheridan makes wellness a top priority. She heads straight for the Plaza’s 111skin Spa to indulge in some well-earned rejuvenation. Looking forward to her breaks, she shares that her post-meeting facial is officially booked, and she is already counting down the days until she can unwind in the luxurious setting. Between managing social media strategies and capturing the vibrant pulse of the city, these moments of self-care anchor her bustling schedule.
How Does Your Style Present Differently in NYC Versus LA?
The contrast between Sheridan’s bicoastal routines extends far beyond her favorite dining spots and wellness rituals, influencing how she approaches fashion on a daily basis. When asked about the differences between her wardrobe choices in the two cities, she explains that the aesthetic landscapes are extremely distinct. People in New York are notably more experimental, and their everyday outfits carry a heightened sense of polish and elevation.
When Sheridan is out and about in Los Angeles, she typically gravitates toward a reliable, classic uniform consisting of comfortable jeans, a simple black t-shirt, and a fun pair of shoes that adds personality to the understated look. In New York, however, her approach shifts entirely. Feeling as though the world is her oyster, she finds herself eager to take more fashion risks and wear something considerably more daring because the city’s inhabitants truly show up and push creative boundaries with their street style.
What’s Your Secret to September Dressing in NYC?
Navigating the transitional weather and demanding schedules of New York Fashion Week requires a strategic approach to wardrobe planning. Sheridan’s primary secret to September dressing in the city centers on versatility and comfort. Because she frequently finds herself out and about for more than 14 hours a day during her trips, she requires pieces that can effortlessly transition from daytime appointments to evening events.
To meet this challenge, she routinely reaches for a cotton babydoll dress that can be easily dressed up or down depending on the occasion. Crafted from breathable material that remains easy to wear throughout a long day of walking and meetings, these lightweight dresses offer the ideal blend of practicality and effortless style.
How Does September Style Differ From Your Winter Style?
While transition months like September demand adaptable, breathable layers to handle lingering summer warmth and brisk autumn breezes, Sheridan notes that the fundamental philosophy of her wardrobe remains consistent throughout the year. In fact, she points out that the only major factor that truly differentiates her September style from her winter style is the weather itself. Always planning ahead for changing forecasts, she shares that she currently has her eyes on a Toteme cotton trench coat that might just be arriving in her mail as we speak, ready to incorporate into her upcoming transitional wardrobe rotations.
Vintage or Runway?
When it comes to sourcing her favorite fashion pieces, Sheridan firmly casts her vote for vintage over brand-new runway items. Currently deep into a major vintage kick, she admits that she could easily spend hours browsing online platforms like The RealReal, hunting down unique, pre-loved garments that add character and history to her personal style collection.
Cotton or Synthetic Fabrics?
Fabric choice plays a crucial role in how Sheridan packs for her bicoastal lifestyle, and her preference is unequivocal: 100 percent cotton. She considers it the most versatile, livable, and effortlessly comfortable fabric available, making it the foundational material for the reliable packing list she relies on every time she travels to the East Coast.
Shake Shack or In-N-Out?
When the conversation turns to casual dining preferences and the classic regional fast-food debate, Sheridan offers a delightfully blended verdict. Rather than choosing just one side of the bicoastal equation, she prefers the best of both worlds, opting for an In-N-Out burger paired with a classic Shake Shack milkshake.
Subway or Driving?
Despite the legendary efficiency of New York City’s subway system and the notorious traffic of Los Angeles, Sheridan’s transportation preference leans toward the open road. She enthusiastically chooses driving, noting that there is simply nothing better than listening to a captivating podcast on a peaceful road trip.
Central Park or Griffith Park?
Asked to choose between the two iconic urban green spaces that define her respective home cities, Sheridan gives the edge to the East Coast landmark. While Griffith Park holds a special place in the landscape of Los Angeles, she maintains that Central Park is ultimately unbeatable, standing as one of her favorite destinations to visit whenever she returns to New York.
