Any retailer looking forward to Black Friday this year is already late.
At a time when inflation remains stubborn—with grocery prices surging again last month and fuel prices still elevated—consumers began holiday shopping a while ago in order to stretch their budgets. Some shoppers even started over the summer months, driven by the need to spread out their expenses over a longer period. Well before November arrived across the country, clear signs of holiday shopping were already evident in the form of early decorations, packed parking lots, and long lines at retail centers, even for relatively limited discounts. According to Meghann Martindale, a principal at real estate firm Avison Young where she serves as senior director of U.S. retail strategy, these early indicators point toward a dynamic retail landscape.
"If that energy is any indication, we’re headed for a solid holiday selling season," Martindale said by email. "The question is how much early spending grows the total and how much simply moves it forward."
In fact, more than half of U.S. consumers this year indicated they wanted to hear about Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals at least a month in advance, according to research from Sinch, a firm that provides technology for customer messaging services like text alerts.
The promotional sales event, which was once traditionally thought of as the single day immediately following Thanksgiving, is also stretching much later into the season, according to data from Bank of America. Nearly 30% of U.S. consumers now plan to do the vast majority of their holiday shopping in early to mid-December. This represents a significant increase from about 20% last year, effectively overshadowing traditional Black Friday as a new peak time for retail activity, the researchers found.
The fourth quarter remains a critical, make-or-break period for a multitude of retailers. Fortunately for the industry, more than 90% of U.S. consumers are buying gifts this year, with 65% also purchasing a treat for themselves, according to a comprehensive survey from The Harris Poll conducted in October. However, these shoppers have a great deal more on their lists than just presents. More than half of consumers plan to host a holiday gathering, 65% intend to travel, and 60% are planning to attend a show or other seasonal event.
All of those activities cost money during an economic era when personal finances continue to feel strained.
"It doesn’t mean Black Friday is going away," Lora Monafred, head of consumer card products at Bank of America, said by phone. "It just might mean that the holiday shopping window is becoming more spread out, and consumers are giving themselves more time to compare prices. Maybe keep an eye out for a different promotion and make sure that they’re getting the best deal on what they’re buying."
Shoppers Want Transparency Amid Trust Deficits
Consumer trust in advertised holiday promotions is currently strained, and the growing integration of artificial intelligence into the retail ecosystem is not necessarily helping to alleviate those concerns. More than a third of consumers report that in recent years they have actually encountered a holiday-themed scam attempt, according to data from Bank of America.
On a global scale, about a fifth of consumers actively distrust promotional pricing during the holidays, while about half trust advertised prices at least somewhat, according to research from the Boston Consulting Group. The firm found that consumer trust tends to be somewhat higher within the United States compared to other international markets.
That trust could erode further in the U.S., however, as federal and state regulators work diligently to uncover and correct what they view as deceptive pricing practices. These instances include situations where prices ring up at the cash register significantly higher than what was originally advertised on the shelf.
In part due to these persistent trust issues, consumers in the United States may be actively moving away from the use of AI shopping assistants. More than 70% of shoppers say they will refrain from using AI tools for their holiday shopping this year, which is a sharp increase from nearly half of consumers who said the same last year. Over a third of respondents state that this hesitation is because AI robs them of the personal aspect of finding and selecting meaningful gifts, while more than a quarter note that it is simply because they do not trust AI-generated product recommendations.
Even so, Boston Consulting Group finds that generative AI is simultaneously morphing into a primary tool of choice for finding and comparing products and offers. More than half of consumers are using AI to shop in 2026, marking an 8 percentage point increase year over year.
"As AI becomes a larger shopping channel, U.S. retailers need to ensure their products, prices, and promotions are accurately represented and easily discoverable," Brad Loftus, BCG’s North America retail lead, said by email. "For this holiday season, that means engaging shoppers early and checking how AI-enabled discovery represents them, with transparency at the center of the strategy."
Resale Gains Traction While Social Media Influence Fades
In their continuous search to find worthy items without completely bursting their household budgets, consumers are increasingly turning to thrifty shopping habits.
Overall retail spending in October rose 5% compared to the same period last year. Notably, much of that increased spending was concentrated at discount stores, big-box retailers, and secondhand establishments, according to proprietary data from Bank of America.
"We hear a lot of people say, ‘It’s the thought that counts,’" Monafred said. "People are getting creative. Maybe a re-gift exchange. There’s a thriftiness. They’re sticking closer to their budgets, or at least they’re trying to. What we’re seeing is that consumers are resilient. They’re still spending, but they’re shifting how they’re spending."
Buying a used gift remains a process that is still a little tricky for many shoppers, according to Janine Stichter, a consumer retail and lifestyle brands analyst at U.S. Bancorp’s BTIG.
"I don’t know that it’s entirely mainstream, but it definitely seems to be shifting in that direction. And it probably depends a little bit on who you’re talking about," she said by phone. "I think luxury sites like The RealReal that are better at authenticating and can deliver you goods in more of a close-to-new fashion are doing better, seeing that gifting benefit."
At the same time, fewer consumers appear to be influenced by popular social media applications like TikTok or Instagram when making purchasing decisions. More than 60% of consumers state that viral online content has no influence whatsoever on their holiday purchases. Furthermore, direct shopping via social media platforms plummeted dramatically, falling from 35% a year ago down to just 14% this year, according to Bank of America findings.
Physical Stores Still Play a Vital Role
Shopping online to find gifts, compare prices, and make purchases is, in many ways, the preferred channel for consumers across nearly all income levels and generational cohorts. Yet, physical brick-and-mortar stores still matter immensely to the modern retail experience.
"Honestly, it’s both. Consumers move seamlessly between stores and digital. To them, it’s now all retail," Martindale said. "However, each serves a vastly different purpose, and stores take on special meaning during the holidays."
Shopping in person remains a delightful experience for many due to the festive lights, seasonal decorations, special events, social gatherings, and the joy of spontaneous discovery. The sense of community that is forged in an actual physical location can also prove exceptionally helpful to retailers looking to build lasting customer relationships, according to Anjali Burkins, senior director of North America retail strategy at O9 Solutions.
"Community can be one of a retailer’s most valuable tools, not just for driving foot traffic but for understanding what customers actually want," Burkins said by email. "I know a beauty retailer that hosts localized events to introduce shoppers to emerging brands they may not otherwise discover. These events create a two-way relationship. Customers get to explore something new, while retailers get a firsthand look at what generates excitement, what resonates and what people are willing to buy."
In-real-life shopping is especially appealing to younger generations, and retail stores that fail to maintain proper merchandising risk turning those valuable customers off entirely, according to Stichter.
"At a time for the holiday when being in stock is extremely important, I think retailers really need to put their best foot forward and not disappoint the consumer when they go to shop in person," she noted.
Physical stores can also make an indelible impression that stays with customers well past the conclusion of the winter season, Martindale added.
"That shared sense of festivity is something you can’t replicate online," she said. "You can buy a gift online in minutes. A holiday shopping outing can become a memory."
