When The New York Times declared the "Dirty Shirley" the drink of the summer back in 2022, it marked a triumphant moment for consumers with a sweet tooth. Fast-forward to the present, and that nostalgic soda shop classic has found a permanent home amid the throwback trends dominating the modern consumer landscape, influencing everything from mainstream food culture to high fashion.

First introduced in the 1930s, the Shirley Temple remains a household name despite enduring disputes over its exact origins and its ties to the famous child star of the same era. Over the decades, the mocktail has evolved right alongside the changing landscape of American culture and cuisine. Given the massive resurgence of functional sodas, it was arguably only a matter of time before the wellness beverage movement took note of the beloved children’s mocktail, leading nearly every major alternative-soda brand to launch its own grenadine-infused formulation.
At its core, a traditional Shirley Temple is a

simple concoction: lemon-lime soda, such as Sprite, Starry, or 7-Up, or even ginger ale, mixed with a splash of grenadine and garnished with a maraschino cherry. It has long been celebrated for its comforting sweetness and distinct fruity profile. For health-conscious fans of the original drink, the appeal of a nutrition-first formula—featuring lower sugar content, reduced calories, and cleaner, recognizable ingredients—is undeniable. Yet, the ultimate test for these modern iterations always comes down to flavor. If a functional beverage fails to deliver on taste, the entire premise falls flat.
To find out how well the modern market measures up, a comprehensive taste test of every healthy Shirley Temple soda currently available was conducted, resulting in a ranked review of the top blends alongside a notable seasonal honorable mention.

The 5 Best Healthy Shirley Temple Sodas
Kicking off the market offerings is Slice, a functional soda brand with deep roots dating back to the 1980s. Following a strategic rebrand in 2025, Slice returned to grocery shelves with a low-sugar, gut-friendly formulation spanning multiple flavors, putting it in direct competition with established functional beverage giants like Olipop and Poppi. Taking the traditional "splash of grenadine" concept literally, the brand’s modern rendition leans heavily into the bright, citrusy notes reminiscent of 7-Up or Sprite, complemented by a delicate whisper of maraschino cherry. While the beverage delivers a refreshingly light and bubbly profile that will appeal to palates favoring tartness over sweetness, strict purists of the classic mocktail may find themselves looking for a richer, more sugary punch.

As a self-described superfan of Olipop, expectations were high upon discovering the brand was releasing its own take on the Shirley Temple. Known for reimagined classics like Vintage Cola, Classic Grape, and Strawberry Vanilla, Olipop typically captures traditional flavor profiles with a modern, prebiotic twist. However, this particular blend introduced an entirely unexpected flavor direction, featuring prominent notes of vanilla that evoke a classic cream soda. While the cherry element is present, it reads more like a sophisticated, nuanced blend of mixed berries and cherries—striking a balance between sweet and tart. Although undeniably delicious, it departs slightly from the authentic flavor profile of a traditional Shirley Temple, though it easily wins points for aesthetic can design.
For consumers seeking a more direct flavor connection to the original mocktail, Poppi delivers a much bolder experience. As a viral internet favorite, expectations were naturally elevated upon cracking open a can. The aroma is immediately unmistakable, dominated by a heavy, unmistakable scent of grenadine and maraschino cherry. That aromatic intensity translates directly to the palate, delivering a syrupy, sweet punch that leaves no doubt about its inspiration. While the flavor profile successfully captures the essence of a Shirley Temple, the intensity can prove slightly overwhelming, making a half-can more than enough for a single sitting. It edges out competitors in terms of authenticity to its roots, though a touch less saccharine sweetness and a stronger citrus balance would elevate the overall drink.

Celebrity-backed spirit brands defined a previous era of consumer goods, but recent years have seen major stars pivot away from distilleries and toward non-alcoholic, gastronomic ventures. In September 2025, actor Ben Stiller launched Stiller’s Soda, an all-natural beverage line built on a "no-biotics" philosophy that deliberately distances itself from the gut-friendly marketing narratives of competing functional soda brands. While the brand debuted with four distinct flavors, Stiller developed the line with one specific hero in mind: the Shirley Temple, inspired by his lifelong love of the beverage. Formulated with real cane sugar and zero artificial aftertaste, the drink leads with a crisp lemon-lime profile backed by a subtle dark cherry sweetness. While it operates more as a sophisticated, grown-up twist on the throwback classic rather than an exact carbon copy, it successfully bridges the gap between nostalgia and modern ingredients.
Standing out as the top performer among the dedicated functional soda options, Bloom Pop delivered a surprise win in the ultimate search for a healthy Shirley Temple. As the only flavor tested from the Bloom Pop lineup, it emerged as the closest modern match to its bubbly namesake. The beverage features a delightfully sweet, cherry-forward flavor profile that feels light on the tongue and exceptionally easy to drink. A subtle touch of tartness emerges at the finish of each sip, echoing the deep pomegranate undertones characteristic of authentic grenadine, which is traditionally crafted from pomegranate juice, water, and sugar. Furthermore, it claims the title of the "lightest" option among the group, coming in at a modest 20 calories and three grams of sugar per serving while capturing the essential hallmarks of aroma and taste.

An Honorable Mention for Winter Energy
While not traditionally categorized under the umbrella of gut-friendly functional sodas, CELSIUS introduced a limited-edition winter seasonal flavor that warrants a strong honorable mention. Formulated with zero sugar, no artificial colors, and seven essential vitamins—including vitamin C, riboflavin, and vitamin B12—to support energy and immune health, the sparkling beverage delivers a functional kick with 200 milligrams of caffeine per can. Despite its energy-drink positioning, the profile is surprisingly smooth and refreshing, featuring a subtle, unmistakably cherry-forward Shirley Temple taste. Clocking in at just 15 calories per can, it provides a smart, energizing alternative for consumers seeking that nostalgic flavor profile alongside an afternoon boost.
