As someone who tests beauty products for a living, trying out a wide variety of formulas comes with the territory. Having a fully stocked beauty cupboard at my disposal means I am fortunate enough to bring a constant rotation of new beauty products home for evaluation. In a single year alone, I have tested close to 20 different concealers. I have put countless distinct formulas through their paces, ranging from specialized under-eye concealers that promise to awaken and brighten stubborn dark circles to high-end, luxury creamy concealer formulations costing £40 and upward. Yet, despite the endless parade of high-end innovations crossing my desk, there is one humble drugstore concealer that I return to time and time again—and it costs just £10.
Maybelline Instant Eraser Concealer
Coverage: Medium-to-full, buildable coverage
Finish: Natural matte
Shades: 11
What Makes This Concealer So Iconic?
This is not a newly launched product—in fact, it made its debut 16 years ago back in 2010—and yet, when I speak with my fellow beauty editors, there is a unanimous consensus that Maybelline’s Instant Eraser Concealer remains one of the best concealer formulas on the market. The fact that it commands a mere £10 price tag makes its enduring status as a drugstore icon all the more remarkable.

It had been a few years since I last kept a tube in my regular rotation; however, I recently picked one up again and was immediately reminded of why this has remained one of the absolute best options available. Frankly, I am annoyed at myself for ever stepping away from it in the first place.
For those not already acquainted with the cult-favorite item, understanding its core mechanics is straightforward. This cream concealer comes topped with a specialized sponge applicator, which requires a simple twist of the collar to release and dispense the product. While the built-in sponge makes rapid application effortless—especially when you are applying makeup on the go—the formula particularly excels when used specifically on the delicate skin under the eye area. If you struggle with dark circles, this brightening formula manages to disguise them effortlessly. While no cosmetic concealer can ever be claimed to be totally and permanently "crease-proof," this particular formula performs exceptionally well. It resists settling into fine lines around the eyes, particularly when the skin is properly prepped with an eye cream beforehand.
Before
The hydrating, creamy nature of the formula also makes it an ideal concealer for dry skin types. It glides smoothly over fine lines and blurs away dark spots, eventually drying down into a convincing, skin-like, natural matte finish. Furthermore, if your daily routine requires a higher level of coverage, the product layers easily, building up to a robust full-coverage finish without looking heavy.

While I predominantly use this formula under my eyes, I frequently bring it around the contours of my nose and chin as well. It does a remarkably proficient job of concealing my rosacea, making it an invaluable asset on those challenging skin days when you require extra coverage and color correction.
After
There is a tremendous amount to appreciate about this cosmetic staple, particularly when factoring in its accessible price point. However, looking at the product objectively, there are a few practical considerations to keep in mind. I do wish the available shade range was significantly more expansive, particularly for deep skin tones. With an offering of only 11 shades, finding an exact, seamless match can occasionally prove tricky; for personal reference, I wear the shade Light 01. Additionally, when you first break the seal and use the twist-up mechanism on a brand-new tube, it can take a couple of turns for the product to travel upward and dispense, so it is wise to move slowly to avoid pushing out too much product at once.
My initial skepticism regarding the sponge applicator has largely faded over the years. Learning that the applicator is antimicrobial offers peace of mind when keeping a tube stashed in a handbag for daytime top-ups, though standard hygiene practices dictate that giving the sponge a gentle clean when needed remains a good idea. Ultimately, having the sponge integrated into the packaging is genuinely useful; it fits precisely into the concave contour of the inner eye area and eliminates the need to carry a separate makeup brush.

My Verdict
This concealer is remarkable, frequently outperforming luxury formulations that command prices three times higher. After picking it up once again following a multi-year hiatus from my daily makeup bag, I was instantly reminded of why this product retains its legendary status. It effortlessly blurs across fine lines, disguises dark circles and dark spots, and delivers heavy-duty coverage precisely when you need it. Crucially, it always applies smoothly and never looks cakey on the skin.
It remains almost unbelievable that it continues to retail for only £10. While the limited shade range of 11 options is a notable drawback that leaves room for improvement, finding a suitable match for your skin tone unlocks a reliable product that will not disappoint.
Shop Now:
Maybelline Instant Eraser Concealer

How We Tested
I have utilized this concealer for over 10 years, and I recently purchased a fresh tube specifically to put it through a rigorous modern evaluation. Having tested a vast cross-section of concealer formulas in my professional capacity as a beauty editor, I am uniquely positioned to compare how this affordable formulation fares against both contemporary drugstore competitors and luxury department store counterparts. I tested the concealer intensively around my eyes, nose, and chin to gauge its performance across various skin textures and concerns, carefully weighing its practical pros and cons.
Why Trust Us
At Who What Wear UK, our team understands that beauty is never a one-size-fits-all proposition. Over the years, our editors have tested thousands of individual products spanning skincare, makeup, hair care, and nail treatments. We work closely with trusted industry experts—including board-certified dermatologists, professional makeup artists, and leading cosmetic insiders—to ensure that every buying guide and product review is thoroughly researched, inclusive, and genuinely relevant to our readers.
Our editorial focus remains centered on formulas that deliver tangible, real-world results. Whether we are evaluating affordable high-street favorites or luxury investments, our product selections are driven by ingredient science, practical performance, and the honest standard of what we would willingly recommend to a close friend.
